ZorantaGuides
Gradeleaf

Gradeleaf › Guides

Total Points vs Weighted Grades: Which Gradebook Setup to Use

In a total points gradebook, the grade is all points earned divided by all points possible, so a 100-point test counts ten times as much as a 10-point quiz. In a weighted gradebook, each category gets a fixed share of the grade, such as Tests 70% and Homework 30%, however many points sit inside it.

The same scores can give a different final grade under each system. The example below shows how, and the rest of this page covers when each setup works better.

An open gradebook with a red pencil on a teacher's desk

Total points vs weighted grades: the same scores, two results

A student completes ten homework assignments worth 10 points each and two tests worth 50 points each.

CategoryPoints earnedPoints possibleCategory percentage
Homework9510095%
Tests6010060%
Total155200
SystemCalculationGrade
Total points155 ÷ 200 × 10077.5%
Weighted: Tests 70%, Homework 30%60 × 0.70 + 95 × 0.30 = 42 + 28.570.5%

Under total points, homework and tests each make up half the grade, because each has 100 points. Under the weighting, tests decide most of the grade only because the teacher set them to 70%. Neither result is wrong; they answer different questions about the student's work.

Gradeleaf

Gradeleaf works with weighted categories: you give each category its share, enter scores as points out of any total, and can make an assessment count ×2 inside its category. Get it on Google Play

What is a weighted grading system?

A weighted grading system splits the grade into categories and gives each a percentage of the final grade. Inside a category, scores are averaged, either as percentages or as points earned over points possible. Then each category average is multiplied by its weight and the results are added.

The point value of a single assignment then matters only inside its own category. Adding twenty homework tasks does not make homework count for more of the grade; it only spreads the homework share across more tasks.

Our step-by-step guide on how to calculate weighted grades has worked examples, including what to do when a category is still empty.

The hidden weights in a total points gradebook

A points gradebook is weighted too: each category's share is its points divided by all the points in the term. The share moves every time you add an assignment.

Point afterHomework pointsTest pointsHomework share
Week 350050 ÷ 50 = all of it
Week 610050100 ÷ 150 = 67%
End of term150200150 ÷ 350 = 43%

Early in the term, a student who does every homework task can look like an A student, then drop after the tests are added. Students and parents see that as a sudden fall, even though nothing about the work changed. If you use total points, plan the point values for the whole term in advance so the shares end where you intend.

Which one to choose

Total pointsWeighted categories
Easy for students to checkYes: add up the pointsNeeds the weights and a short calculation
Category shares fixed all termNo: they move as assignments are addedYes
Changing an assignment's point valueChanges its influence on the gradeChanges its influence only inside its category
Empty category early in the termNot an issueLeave it out until it has scores
Fits a school policy like "tests are 60%"Only if you plan the points to matchDirectly

Switching systems partway through a term

Changing from total points to weighted (or back) after grades are published changes every student's average, sometimes by several points. If you have to switch, do it between terms, or announce it with a before-and-after example such as the one above so students can see why their number moved.

  1. Write the categories and weights, or the planned point totals, into the syllabus.
  2. Set the gradebook up the same way before the first score goes in.
  3. Check one student's grade by hand after the first few assessments.
  4. Keep the same setup until the end of the term.

Whichever system you use, convert to a letter only at the end. The letter grade percentage scale lists the usual cut-offs.

Gradeleaf

Set the weights once, then just enter scores

Gradeleaf keeps the category shares you choose for the whole term and shows each student's average per category and overall.

Get it on Google Play

iPhone version coming soon

More guides

All guides

Published by Zoranta, the developer of Gradeleaf.