ZorantaGuides
Gradeleaf

Gradeleaf › Guides

Standards-Based Grading Scale: 1–4 Levels and Percentage Conversion

A standards-based grading scale reports how well a student has met each learning standard, usually on four levels: 4 exceeds the standard, 3 meets it, 2 is approaching it and 1 is beginning. A 3 is the target, not a B: it means the student can do what the standard asks.

There is no single official chart for turning 1–4 levels into percentages or letter grades. Districts publish their own, and the same 3 can become 85% in one school and 90% in another. Below are the level descriptions, two example conversion charts and the main ways teachers combine several scores on one standard.

Different grading stamps lined up on a desk

The standards based grading scale 1-4

LevelCommon labelWhat it usually means
4Exceeds / AdvancedApplies the standard in new or more complex situations without help
3Meets / ProficientDoes what the standard asks, independently and accurately
2Approaching / DevelopingGets the simpler parts right; makes errors on the full task
1Beginning / EmergingCan do parts of it with support

Some schools add half levels (3.5, 2.5) for work that sits between two descriptions, and some use a 1–3 or 1–5 scale instead. A few keep a 0 for "no evidence yet". Whatever the range, the labels should describe what the student did, so a parent reading "2" knows what is missing.

Writing the levels as a short rubric for each standard helps more than the numbers alone. For a standard such as "solves two-step equations", level 3 might be "solves them correctly without prompts", and level 4 "writes and solves an equation from a word problem".

Gradeleaf

Gradeleaf includes a 1–4 standards-based scale: you enter the level directly, and it averages levels with the category shares and assessment weights you set. Get it on Google Play

Standards based grading scale to percentage

Report cards and transcripts often still need a percentage or a letter. Here are two example charts that schools use. They are examples only: use the chart your school or district has adopted.

LevelExample chart AExample chart B
4100%100%
3.595%90%
390%85%
2.582%77%
275%70%
1.567%62%
160%55%

Notice what a straight division would do. Dividing the level by 4 turns a 3 (proficient) into 75%, which reads as a C on a typical letter scale, and a 2 into 50%, a failing grade. That is why districts use a chart rather than the raw fraction: the chart keeps "meets the standard" in the range people read as a good grade.

Standards based grading scale 1 4 conversion chart to letters

Some schools skip percentages and convert the average level straight to a letter. An example:

Average levelExample letter
3.50 to 4.00A
3.00 to 3.49B
2.50 to 2.99C
2.00 to 2.49D
Below 2.00F

If your school uses percentage bands for letters, see our letter grade percentage scale for the usual cut-offs.

Combining several scores on one standard

A student is usually assessed on the same standard several times. How those scores are combined changes the result. Take three scores on one standard, in order: 2, 3, 3.

MethodHow it worksResult
MeanAdd and divide by the number of scores(2 + 3 + 3) ÷ 3 = 2.67
Most recentUse the last score3
ModeUse the score that appears most often3
Decaying average (65%)Each new score counts 65%, the running result 35%2 → 2.65 → 2.88

Worked through, the decaying average starts at 2. The second score gives 0.35 × 2 + 0.65 × 3 = 2.65. The third gives 0.35 × 2.65 + 0.65 × 3 = 2.88 (rounded).

The mean keeps early mistakes in the grade for the whole term. The other methods give more weight to what the student can do now, which is the idea behind standards-based grading. Whichever you use, use the same one for every student and say so in your grading policy.

Putting a 1-4 scale into a gradebook

  1. Enter the level itself (1, 2, 3, 4 or a half level), not a percentage.
  2. Group assessments by standard or by strand so each one has its own average.
  3. Decide how levels combine (mean, most recent or a weighting that favors later work).
  4. Convert to a percentage or letter only at the end, using your school's chart.
  5. Keep a short note on what the student still needs for the next level.

Behaviour, effort and homework completion are usually reported separately in standards-based grading, so they do not change the academic level. If they are part of your school's model, give them their own category instead of adjusting the levels.

For background on why schools move to standards-based reporting, ASCD's article Grades That Show What Students Know is a useful read.

Gradeleaf

Keep levels per standard, all term

With Gradeleaf you can set up a category for each standard or strand, enter 1–4 levels, and see each student's average per category on their own page.

Get it on Google Play

iPhone version coming soon

More guides

All guides

Sources

Published by Zoranta, the developer of Gradeleaf.