ZorantaGuides
DriveLedger

DriveLedger › Guides

Standard Mileage vs Actual Expenses: How to Choose

The standard mileage method multiplies your business miles by the IRS rate for the year. The actual expense method adds up what the car really cost you (fuel, insurance, repairs, depreciation or lease payments and so on) and claims the business-use share. Business-related parking and tolls can be added with either one.

A car you drive a lot for business and that is cheap to run usually does better on the standard rate. An expensive car with modest business mileage can do better on actual expenses. The first year you use a car for business matters, because the choice you make then limits what you can do later.

A parked car beside receipts, a map and coins

Standard mileage vs actual expenses at a glance

Standard mileage rateActual expenses
How it is worked outBusiness miles × IRS rateTotal car costs × business-use %
Records you needMileage logMileage log plus receipts for every cost
CoversRunning costs and depreciation, built into the rateFuel, oil, repairs, tires, insurance, registration, licenses, garage rent, depreciation or lease payments
Added on topBusiness parking and tolls; business share of car loan interest and personal property tax if self-employedBusiness parking and tolls, interest and taxes as part of the costs
Paperwork effortLowHigher

Both methods need a mileage log. With the standard rate, the log is the deduction. With actual expenses, the log sets the business-use percentage that every cost is multiplied by.

DriveLedger

In the US, Canada, the UK and Australia, DriveLedger applies the official standard rate for each trip's date and keeps a running estimate of the deduction. Get it on Google Play

Worked examples

The figures below are examples. The standard mileage rate here is an illustrative 70 cents a mile; use the rate the IRS publishes for your tax year on its standard mileage rates page.

Example 1: high business mileage, modest car

ItemFigure
Total miles in the year15,000
Business miles9,000 (60%)
Standard mileage9,000 × $0.70 = $6,300
Actual costs: fuel $2,400, insurance $1,500, repairs and maintenance $900, tires $300, registration $200, depreciation $3,000$8,300
Actual expenses$8,300 × 60% = $4,980

The standard rate wins by $1,320 here, and it needs far less paperwork.

Example 2: lower mileage, expensive car

ItemFigure
Total miles in the year10,000
Business miles4,000 (40%)
Standard mileage4,000 × $0.70 = $2,800
Actual costs: fuel $1,600, insurance $2,400, repairs $600, registration $600, depreciation $8,000$13,200
Actual expenses$13,200 × 40% = $5,280

Here actual expenses come out ahead, mostly because of depreciation. Depreciation on passenger cars has yearly caps and special rules (and a car used 50% or less for business has its own limits), so the real figure may be lower than a simple estimate. Publication 463 covers those limits in its depreciation chapter.

The first-year rule and switching between methods

This is where people get caught. Per IRS Publication 463 and the Schedule C instructions:

So the standard rate in year one keeps both doors open. Actual expenses in year one, with accelerated depreciation, can close one of them for the life of that car.

Switching from standard to actual later

If you move an owned car from the standard rate to actual expenses, you have to use straight-line depreciation for its remaining estimated useful life, and the standard rate is treated as having included some depreciation, which lowers the car's basis. A tax professional can work out the basis for you.

Which method fits which driver

SituationOften fits betterWhy
Rideshare or delivery driving in an economical carStandard rateMany miles, low cost per mile
Real estate agent with a new, costly vehicle and moderate business milesWorth comparing actual expensesLarge depreciation and insurance
Leased carDecide carefully at the startThe choice holds for the whole lease
You do not keep receiptsStandard rateActual expenses need proof of each cost
Older car that is fully depreciatedUsually standard rateNo depreciation left to claim

If you are not sure, run both numbers for the first year using your log and receipts. Keeping receipts for one year costs little and shows you how far apart the two methods are for your car.

How to compare the two for your own car

  1. Log every trip for the year, with the odometer reading at the start and end of the year.
  2. Add up business miles and divide by total miles to get the business-use percentage.
  3. Multiply business miles by the IRS standard rate for each part of the year. In years when the IRS changed the rate mid-year, trips before and after the change use different rates.
  4. Total your actual costs from receipts and statements, including a depreciation figure from Publication 463 or your tax software.
  5. Multiply the actual costs by the business-use percentage and compare.
  6. Add business parking and tolls to whichever method you use.
This is general information, not tax advice. Depreciation limits, the treatment of interest and the rates themselves change and depend on your circumstances. Check Publication 463 and the Schedule C instructions on irs.gov, or speak to a tax professional, before you choose.
DriveLedger

Know your standard-rate figure all year

Log trips in DriveLedger as you drive and the estimated standard mileage deduction builds up month by month, ready to compare with your actual costs.

Get it on Google Play

iPhone version coming soon

More guides

All guides

Sources

Published by Zoranta, the developer of DriveLedger.